AARUK

 

Home

Contents

- Judicial interpretation relating to Part III : some useful guidance on the meaning of "standards", "serious" and "unacceptable".

- Discipline and questionable PCC decisions : powers, duties and criticisms of the PCC.

- Case Study 1 : procedural irregularities and two perverse decisions in consideration of charges brought under Code Standard 8.

- Case Study 2 (Part 1) : a similar case, involving the apprehension of a real possibility of bias.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Part 2) : the PCC decide and a question of incongruity arises. 

- Note on Part III of the Architects Act 1997.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Part 3) - QC advises that the architect has an obvious and complete defence.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Part 4) - "Judicial nonsense".

- Case Study 2 (continued - Part 5) - A Court decision in favour of the architect.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Parts 6, 7 and 8) - (6) The Court rules architect's application for judicial review "plainly justified" - 14 October 2008; (7) the case is remitted by Consent Order of the High Court - 21 August 2009; and (8) the proceedings are withdrawn - 7 April 2010.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Parts 9 and 10) - Report on outcome of proceedings.

- Case Study 2 (continued - Part 11) - How the Board deals with the result.

 Case Study 2 (continued - Part 12) - ARB misclaims "new evidence".

 Case Study 2 (continued - Part 13) - New Guidance - December 2010.

Discipline and questionable PCC decisions

In 2005 (Case Study 1) the PCC fell under criticism for allowing itself to become merely an instrument for executing a policy of the Board which had since its inception been the subject of criticism (see PII). In 2003 the Royal Institute of British Architects had published a paper " The Status of the Architects Registration Board" anticipating and explaining the mistakes.

The decisions of the PCC in respect of the architects who had taken a principled stand not to return the board's Certificates of Compliance only serves to underscore the criticism.

See Case Study 1 and Case Study 2, Part 1

[ top]

Architects Act
Architects Registration Board
Registration
- education
- competence to practise
Professional standards - the code, etc
PII
discipline
Use of title
Links to websites:
chartered bodies
legislation
- historical notes